Written & Directed by: Scott Beck and Bryan Woods
Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East) are young missionaries for the Mormon Church. They are taking their work door to door when they arrive at the home of Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant). With a storm brewing overhead he invites the girls inside to meet his wife as she cooks them pie. What starts as a detailed and intellectual debate around religion and faith soon becomes something else. A test designed, by Reed, of the girls own faith, intellect and will.
I really enjoyed this, it’s a smart smorgasbord of genres packaged together into tense, taught drama. It encompasses thriller, intellectual drama, locked room mystery, detective story and good old fashioned survival thriller.
It’s basically a three hander centered around Grant’s mysterious, unsettling Mr. Reed and Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East’s smart, if initially naive young missionaries. All three turn in fine performances that build tension and keep the story on track as it swings between its genres.
Grant is excellent as Reed, as his character shifts from pleasant host to an increasingly menacing figure. A smart embodiment of a controlling and coercive threat. His two young co-stars are equally strong, as the growing peril of their situation becomes clear and while their characters become more desperate, they portray a cool headed determination to survive.
The story is smart as it initially builds unease and then looks too misdirect. There is a continual element of mystery as it refuses to rely on twists to keep you engaged instead focusing on intrigue as it reveals the true nature of Reed.
And while it may have some plot holes as it heads towards its conclusion, it earned the right to ignore them.
Heretic is an intelligent thriller/horror. Built on three excellent performances, with Hugh Grant slipping effortlessly into a menacing role. Its clever story takes you seamlessly from intellectual discussion to survival thriller and maintains a sense of intrigue throughout. Tense, smart and you’ll never look at Hugh Grant the same again!