Director: Ti West
Not sure anyone needs a synopsis for Ebenezer, but just in case, it is based on Charles Dickens’ 1843 novella A Christmas Carol. Miserly money lender Ebenezer Scrooge (Johnny Depp) loves money as much as he disdains humanity. On the seventh anniversary of the death of his business partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), he is visited by Marley’s ghost, who warns that his behaviour is dragging him towards a torturous afterlife. Three spirits will follow, and if he heeds their advice there is a chance for him to find redemption and live a good life.
Adapting A Christmas Carol can be a tricky business. So what does handing it to a director with a history in horror-inflected storytelling look like, and was it a success?Partially.
In the plus column, the darkest parts of the story are dark and it is probably not an adaptation for younger audiences; it is atmospheric and at times disturbing. Andrea Riseborough’s Ghost of Christmas Past is a haunting, eyeless spirit with a breathless voice who challenges Ebenezer’s beliefs and reminds him of who he was. Tramell Tillman is an always watchable presence, and his Ghost of Christmas Present has the dominating personality you expect in that role.
On the downside. While it sticks closely to the story in the first two acts, it takes some odd departures in the final one, changes that detract from the message and seem more about giving Depp’s Scrooge a platform than telling the story. Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) and his families story are oddly sidelined in favour of Scrooge’s relationship with his nephew Fred (Sam Claflin), and some other better-known beats are removed, much to its detriment.
But the elephant in the room is Johnny Depp’s central performance. He’s just never a convincing Scrooge; the journey never feels believable and his redemption is not earned. Not terrible, just never quite right.
This is not an awful adaptation and I enjoyed parts. But several directorial choices don’t work, and the biggest problem is that Depp doesn’t work either.